December 20, 2019
By Florida Sportsman Editor
Fly or Jig? And Does It Really Matter?
Black crappie, a.k.a. speckled perch or specks, eagerly bite sinking flies like these.
After live minnows, tiny jigs are probably the most frequently fished baits for crappie. It's possible indeed common, in some areas to use many of these same jigs on a fly rod, whether equipped with a traditional flyline or simply a basic reel holding monofilament line. I prefer to use purpose tied streamers with a chenille body and marabou tail, however. The soft marabou feathers behave more naturally in water than molded soft plastic or yarn.
Jigsheads are molded in specific weights, typically 1/16-or 1/32-ounce for crappie lures. Flies can be tied in this range, or lighter as needed, using lead dumbbell eyes. So long as the fly imitates the size and profile of a minnow, it will probably catch a crappie.
An 8-or 9-foot, 4-or 5-weight fly rod and a fly reel spooled with weight-forward floating line will work well in most situations. Because crappie are found in fresh water, you will not need an anodized, aircraft aluminum reel that will withstand the effects of salt spray. A 2-pound, slab-sided crappie will put up a respectable fight on a light fly rod but the rod's inherent flex is quite forgiving. An entry-level or chain-store fly rod and reel combo will work well to bring most paper mouthed crappie to the gunnels of your boat.
Presenting the Fly
Flies can be fished in several ways to catch crappie. One method is trolling, simply pulling flies through areas where crappie are staging. This is especially effective in open water, days before crappie move to their shoreline cover for spawning. Another proven method is to quietly move a boat along the shoreline or through lily pads and lower the fly along-
side the pads, matted grass, cypress knees, fallen trees and dock pilings. Start by lowering the fly about a foot into the to animate the fibers. If you don't have a bite in about five seconds, lower the fly another foot and let it suspend while you jiggle the rod tip. If you still don't have a bite, lower it yet another foot. After a couple of twitches, slowly raise the fly like a minnow swimming toward the surface. Lift it out of the water and lower
it alongside the next likely object.
One tactic: Set the fly in shoreline pads or other cover and wiggle the rod tip. water and very gently bounce the rod tip Lastly, you might find success casting for crappie in open water. When the fish are suspended around dollar pads in two to four feet, or holding over a channel, they can be readily caught by traditional cast-and-strip fly methods.
The subtle bite of a crappie isn't a mere tap as would be felt on a jigging rod. Instead, you'll feel a tug on the fly line. All you have to do is pull back as if you're stripping line through the guides.
Fly fishing for crappie isn't just a novelty; it's a very effective and enjoyable technique.
Where to Go for Crappie?
The following sample of Florida waters comprises the most recent Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) Top Spots for Crappie:
Lake Monroe, Lake Talquin, Locholoosa Lake/ Orange Lake, Lake Weohyakapka (Walk-in- Water), Lake Weir, Lake Arbuckle, Lake Marian, Lake Marion, West Lake Tohopekaliga, Lake Kissimmee, Mosaic Fish Management Area, Lake Istokpoga, Lake Tra ord. For more details and access, see myfwc.com/fishing/freshwater.
